How we got here
This is the fourth piece I’ve written since rebooting Lightwood earlier this year. Each one has built on the last, and I want to trace that line – because where we’re heading only makes sense if you can see where we started.
In the first article, I named a problem. Australian agriculture is dragging its heels on digital records. We’re dealing with tighter margins, growing compliance requirements and market access demands that all ask for the same thing: reliable information. You can’t provide reliable information if your records are scattered across apps, devices, spreadsheets, filing cabinets and people’s memories. I said then that the lever I’d pull across Australian agriculture tomorrow is transitioning businesses to good digital records. And I meant it.
What I also said – and this matters – is that technology isn’t the hard part. It’s a people, process and technology problem. Buying another software license won’t fix it. Businesses are adopting digital tools, but they’re not becoming digital businesses. That’s the gap.
The second article launched the Industry Innovator Group. The IIG exists because too often, people raise problems but feel no one is listening. It’s a forum for farmers, agronomists, consultants and developers to work together on practical issues. Scientific in foundation, plain in language, built around real farm decisions. The motto: more groundwork, less guesswork. And the test for everything we do is simple – does it improve a real farm decision? If it creates more dashboards, more administration or more noise without improving profitability, production or risk management, it has missed the point entirely.
To those who’ve joined the IIG and answered the survey – thank you. What it confirmed is that a lot of us are having the same experiences, the same frustrations, running into the same limitations. The good news is we can now work on them together. It was that sharing of common challenges that led me to the whitepaper.
The whitepaper was a deliberate gear change. It was intentionally comprehensive because the conversation needed broadening. I wrote it for the wider industry – researchers, institutions, the people who shape the frameworks and funding that influence what happens on the ground.
It made a detailed, referenced case around four key arguments: soil sets the ceiling on what inputs can achieve; a single season’s result can conceal the true cost of a decision; decisions made from memory and disconnected records cannot improve systematically; and a minimum record of account – the MRA – makes decisions reviewable by connecting what was known, recommended, decided, done and measured.
It reflects and expands on the persistent seasonal issues raised in the IIG Survey, but the thread running through the whole paper is inter-generational. The underlying goal isn’t next season’s margin – it’s whether Australian farming businesses can keep producing profitably across decades, not just years. We need the entire industry alongside us, not watching from the sideline, to meet this problem and opportunity.
So the arc has been: here’s the problem; here are the people; here’s the evidence. Now it’s time for the solution.
From concept to structure
The concept of an MRA is sound. But where do you actually start? And won’t it be different for every farm?
That’s where the ‘Master Checklist’ comes in as a proposed practical starting point. It’s the assessment process.
It’s a draft methodology that spans people, process and technology. It doesn’t tell anyone what to decide. Its job is to guide the areas you need to look at and the questions you should be asking, so that each business can work out what minimum connected evidence it actually needs for decision-making, and how they can turn that into a manageable working process.
The Checklist guides you on what to look at, and how you might adapt your approach. The MRA is what you keep as evidence.
The idea of the Master Checklist, like the MRA, needs testing. Both will evolve with real feedback.
Here’s what we expect the Master Checklist to deliver
The Master Checklist organises work into ten areas covering farm plans, soil and agronomic evidence, input costs, machinery and labour, markets, sustainability and compliance, risk, calculation checks, version control and seasonal reconciliation.
Its purpose is to make sure all key farm business, agronomic, operational, financial, sustainability and risk data is collected once, checked properly, and then reused across reporting, decision-making, compliance and seasonal management.
The checklist has five practical benefits:
- First, it improves data quality by creating a standard structure for what must be collected and where it should come from.
- Second, it improves farm management discipline by linking seasonal decisions to paddock-level evidence, cost assumptions, market signals and risk triggers.
- Third, it improves financial visibility by supporting gross margin analysis, input cost tracking, cashflow forecasting and price sensitivity work.
- Fourth, it improves compliance readiness by keeping records, checklists, decision logs and sustainability data organised before an audit or reporting request lands.
- Fifth, it creates the foundation for automation. Once the required data fields and source systems are defined, the Master Checklist can be progressively connected to apps, accounting systems, payroll, irrigation records, supplier data and compliance platforms. This allows reports, alerts, emissions statements, financial summaries and audit packs to be generated faster and with less manual handling.
The real value is creating a repeatable process architecture that allows farmers, agronomists, advisers and supply-chain partners to work from the same structured evidence base. It’s the bridge between farm planning, digital integration and practical advisory services.
Examples could include:
| Core Question | What to look at | Potential Benefits |
| What are we planning to grow, where and why? | Captures crop areas, rotations and paddock plans | The appropriate level of Rotation Review is critical to assess soil chemistry and /or biology constraints; ie managing to soil-born disease issues etc. |
| What is each paddock capable of producing? | Brings together soil tests, PAW, crop history and yield records | Better assessment of soil chemistry is needed to better determine constraints. |
| What will it cost to produce? | Collects input, labour, machinery and fuel costs | Understand paddock variable cost/s (exc overheads) |
| What revenue can we reasonably expect? | Links yield assumptions to forward contracts and market outlooks | Proper assessment of the sensitivity analysis across yield (production) and price (revenue) against commodity outlooks. |
| What are the major risks? | Defines climate, price, input, operational and trigger-based risks | Updated assessment of expected climate volatility, based on regional forecasts and/or geopolitical risk. |
| Are we audit-ready? | Organises compliance, sustainability, spray, water and WHS records | Weight the readiness for emerging compliance requirements; understanding preparation is likely a 2-5 season duration. Ie transition to digital adoption. |
| What needs to change during the season? | Supports monthly plan-vs-actual reviews and trigger-based decisions | How and where do we bring bi-monthly review into the farm management workflow? |
This is the key part: we need to make review part of the season
Those questions only matter if the answers get used.
The ongoing use of the Master Checklist and the underlying MRA shift the preseason farm plan from being a static document into what will become a live, interactive management tool that guides decisions across the season.
The transition involves three things: people who are confident in the data and have a clear reason to maintain it; processes linked to the season, the paddock and the decision; and technology that connects what is collected to what is decided.
With that in mind, agronomists are the critical path for establishing an ongoing review practice. Producers adopt practices their agronomist supports, and agronomists already work with producers on soil constraints, input recommendations and paddock performance.
Private agronomy firms can help farmers agree what will be captured in agronomic evidence, who will confirm it and when it will be reviewed.
Connected records support a broader and more defensible advisory service; closing the loop means comparing actuals with the original plan, explaining material departures and updating decisions while there is still time to act.
This is a fundamental change in how seasonal review, and the industry, operates – but it’s beneficial for both parties.
Seperately, the Master Checklist can work across other teams, like accounting and admin, for the cost and compliance decision-making that happens in parallel.
Why now
I’ve had hundreds of conversations with farming businesses over the years. My honest estimate is that roughly one in five are keeping the kind of connected digital records that would let them review decisions properly across seasons – a picture the IIG survey broadly confirmed. That number hasn’t materially shifted in five to ten years. We’re not short of software. We’re short of a working process that people actually follow.
Now is the time for testing because this is when we make decisions for next season. If you’re an agronomist or a farmer reading this, the window is narrow. The methodology needs to be worked through and fed back on before summer is out – by the end of January at the latest. Those involved need to subscribe to the process before the season starts, or it doesn’t happen.
Some businesses are already making progress with what they have. The Checklist is an attempt to give that progress a common baseline, not to replace it. If we wait, we effectively miss the window for the upcoming year. Another season goes by with the same disconnected records, the same decisions made from memory, the same gaps that nobody closes. I don’t think we can afford that.
The goal for next year is straightforward: a minimum digital record for every participating farm. Not a perfect system. Not a polished product. A working record that connects what was planned to what was done to what happened.
Start ugly. Get the discipline in place. Refine from there.
The ask, and where our IIG members come in
The whitepaper made an honest admission: whether an MRA changes decisions or improves returns is untested. The case is that the logic is sound, the evidence for each component is established, and the tools to build and maintain the record exist. The necessary next step is to test it.
Noting there are two things being tested here: the first is whether the Checklist is a workable, helpful process. The second is whether the minimum record it produces actually changes how decisions get made for the better.
This is that next step. I’m looking for innovative farmers and agronomists who are willing to work through the Master Checklist against their own operations. The questions are practical:
- Are your existing processes and tools fit for purpose?
- What would you change, drop or add?
- Where are the gaps – and what might fill them?
- Does the checklist help, or does it add burden without value?
- Were you able to develop a minimum record of account?
- Did it give you a better understanding of true, long-term outcomes?
- Did it help you make better decisions?
We’ll consider the test successful if participants can produce a connected record linking plan to action to result for at least one paddock, without the process becoming unworkable alongside their existing commitments. If it takes significantly longer than expected or produces records that don’t get used, that tells us something important too.
Even if the framework changes after testing, the process of working through it gives you a clearer picture of where your own records stand and where the gaps are.
Or, if the test shows it doesn’t work, we’ll say so – that’s as useful a finding as proving it does.
This isn’t a pilot with a gate and a waiting list. If you’re in, reach out through the IIG or contact me directly. You’ll get the Checklist, work through it against your own operation, and tell us what’s wrong with it while there’s still time to act on the feedback. The IIG was built for exactly this: real people, real problems, real feedback, practical solutions. The results from this test are what give institutions something concrete to evaluate. We start with the people willing to do the work, and take the evidence to the wider industry from there.
If you’ve been following this series, you’ve seen the progression. We identified the problem. We gathered the people. We built the evidence base. Now we need to find out if the solution works. The only way to do that is to put it in front of the people who’ll use it.
What’s next
The steps we’ve gone through so far:
- The Master Checklist establishes what to collect, who collects it and where it comes from.
- The Minimum Record of Account is that connected evidence season after season.
- Digital integration progressively automates the capture and connection of that evidence
Next:
- Our next article will examine the Paddock Gross Margin Engine – an economic assessment that can help to review profitability measures over multiple seasons, rather than just this one. This is the part where we tie it all together, and ensure we can keep the lights on for many years to come.
I said in my first article that Australian agriculture has a huge opportunity in front of it, and that we just need to stop walking past the solutions that are already within reach. I still believe that. The difference now is we’ve got a starting point to prove it.
Geevesy.